Search  
Friday, November 21, 2008 ..:: Discussions ::.. Register  Login
A place for discussions about the writings of David Sherman and Dan Cragg, including fiction and non-fiction, as well as non-Starfist areas of interest.  Participating in these forums requires registration.
 Starfirst Forum Minimize
SPOILER ALERT! Please keep in mind when reading these forums that posters are likely to
reveal information about the plots or outcome of books you haven't yet read.
SearchForum Home
  Starfist: Force Recon  Force Recon General Discussion  "Heartbreak Rid...
 Re: "Heartbreak Ridge"
 
Finucane
1932 posts
2nd
Joined
1/25/2006

Re: "Heartbreak Ridge"
Posted: 27 Aug 06 4:26 AM
Highly recommended.
Teufel Panzer MK4
1037 posts
3rd
Joined
7/1/2006

Re: "Heartbreak Ridge"
Posted: 27 Aug 06 1:29 PM
Then on my next run, I shall sally forth and aquire this film...
armyblank
200 posts
5th
Joined
10/22/2006

Re: "Heartbreak Ridge"
Posted: 24 Oct 06 3:56 PM
heat break is a classic "can you believe this stuff" movie.  we watched it about as often as Stripes or SGT Bilko.
Admiral Link
292 posts
5th
Joined
8/9/2007

Re: "Heartbreak Ridge"
Posted: 16 Oct 07 5:53 PM
 mclark wrote
 Finucane wrote
Deadders:  Clint Eastwood has made some dogs of movies over the years and "Hearbreak Ridge" was one of the shaggiest.  No criticism of you intended.  Never criticize anyone for the movies they like, the booze they drink, or their dogs.


I'm glad you feel that way, because I really liked that movie.  And I thought Eastwood did a decent job, myself. 

What I do get upset with is watching a military movie where they get too many things wrong.  My wife hates watching war movies with me because I can be depended upon to leap upon everything that is inauthentic (so far as I can tell, as my knowledge is not encyclopedic).  I especially hate bad special effects.  Like somebody throws a fragmentation grenade and it looks like they threw an incendiary of some kind -- big flamy barrooom.  Frags don't produce that kind of smoke and flame.  One recent movie comes to mind as especially crappy in that regard, and that was Windtalkers.  Fake artillery and grenade explosions everywhere.  It made me sick.

 But...the belief that you salute a MOH winner regardless of his rank is an old wives' tale.  The service regs and age-old tradition are quite clear, a salute is rendered ONLY to a person based on rank, nothing else.



And only while in uniform, on top of that. However, I was on leave one time but still on post and just walking around in civies near 9th Division HQ (Ft. Lewis) enjoying the spring weather, when the division commander's jeep drove by.  I knew I was in civies and I didn't have to give him the time of day, let alone salute, but dammit that was my division commander and I had a lot of esprit de corps, so I saluted him.  He didn't seem to mind and saluted me back.


Well in Windtalkers, maybe frags grenade was over exagerated but artillery uses High Explosive shells not normal shells. Also thats Hollywood exagerates things with specials effects. Windtalkers was a good movie and the Heartbreak Ridge was okay nothing speical about it. All I see is Clinteastwood training a bunch of recruits, trying to piece his marriage together and showing great concerns about his recruits being used as cannon folder.


Howdy! I'm with the County Health Inspector ... okay there goes your "A" rating - Nick Kang
Alisium
135 posts
www.usmc.mil
5th
Joined
10/18/2007

Re: "Heartbreak Ridge"
Posted: 07 Jan 08 11:57 PM Modified By Alisium  on 1/8/2008 12:19:28 AM)

It was a nice feel good movie. I actually did enjoy it.  But, it's one full of moments that made me whince. I especially love how they tried to play of Camp Talega (in Camp Pendleton just south of San Onofre) as Lejeune, on the east coast.

If you saw the movie "Jarhead" you'll notice the rifle range they use there is the same exact range they use in "Heartbreak Ridge". I think that they tried to pass that off as Lejeune too. Can't remember though.

Just a couple bones to pick, that I can remember:

Batallion Recon is not subordinate to a company. (Can't remember if they were Batallion or Force, no matter as a division is even higher yet.)

You never run out in the middle of a linear danger area and "spray and pray".

You'll never see a group of batallion or Force Recon act like that. Those guys go through too much crap and work too damned hard to act like those monkeys when left unsupervised. They are the professional's profesional. Way cool and laid back too.

And nobody comes over from supply to command a company of Marines.

 


Photobucket
  Starfist: Force Recon  Force Recon General Discussion  "Heartbreak Rid...

Forum Home  Search         

Copyright 2006 by Mike Clark   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement